Bewitched pulled off a switcheroo no spell could explain: Darrin Stephens suddenly had a different face. Dick York originated the role, bumbling his way through Endora’s schemes and Samantha’s nose-twitches with real comic charm. But off-screen, York was dealing with a serious back injury that eventually caught up with him — he collapsed on set and had to step away from the show. Producers brought in Dick Sargent to finish the run, and he played the role for the show’s final three seasons. Fans have been debating their favorite Darrin ever since. Which Darren gets your vote?
